Monday, January 14, 2008

Overlooked Performances - Best Supporting Actress

The front-runners in this category are Cate Blanchett (absolutely deserving for her brilliant turn in I'm Not There) and Amy Ryan (equally deserving for her amazing character work in Gone Baby Gone). Also getting a lot of mention are Tilda Swinton (Michael Clayton), Saoirse Ronan and Vanessa Redgrave (both from Atonement). I have no problem with the first two — I haven't seen Swinton's film and Ronan was haunting in hers — but Redgrave's inclusion is a head-scratcher. She appears in Atonement for about five minutes total and, while she's quite moving, it's simply not "best of" fare. Ruby Dee (American Gangster) is also in the mix, along with Catherine Keener (Into the Wild), Marisa Tomei (Before the Devil Knows You're Dead) and Jennifer Garner (Juno).

OK, that's all fine and good. But what about these four women, who I've yet to see given serious award consideration?

Allison Janney - Juno


She has a small role and fifth billing behind a quartet of amazing performers, but Janney still manages to steal just about every scene she's in. Funny, strong and smart, she plays the most sympathetic stepmom in recent memory.

Kelly MacDonald - No Country for Old Men


In a movie all about the evil (and good) men do, it was the woman who best embodied the film's soul. Forget for a moment that MacDonald has a thick Scottish brogue and somehow pulls off an authentic Texas accent — reward her depiction in just a few scenes of a character so innocent, devoted and tenacious that she proves herself tougher than all the tough guys circling her.

Leslie Mann - Knocked Up


In the year's funniest film, Mann delivered big laughs and quite a bit of drama, particularly in her 'driveway' fight scene with Paul Rudd as well as her meltdown outside a nightclub. With the film's runaway success, she once seemed like a sure thing for a nomination, but the trail has gone cold.

Tabu - The Namesake


This role could also be classified as a lead, as The Namesake is the mother's story even more than the titular young man's. Gorgeous Indian actress Tabu traces Ashima's path from an innocent experiencing America for the first time to the matriarch of a proud Indian-American family, before retiring to the simple life she always longed for. Beautiful work.

Golden Globes make things interesting


While the Golden Globes "ceremony" was pretty laughable (it consisted of Mary Hart and her cohorts reading the nominees and winners on a cheesy stage for all of 30 minutes) the results threw a bit of a wrench into the Oscar works.

The Globes really spread the wealth, handing out two wins apiece to a handful of films (Atonement, No Country For Old Men, The Diving Bell and the Butterfly and Sweeney Todd). The Best Picture winners were Atonement, getting a needed boost as its Oscar chances have been sagging recently, and Sweeney Todd, which has a fair chance at the Oscar.

Juno was "hurt" the most, losing not only the Best Picture (Musical or Comedy) category but in screenplay and Best Actress as well. However, the film is tearing up the box office, it's the one light film in the mix and it should appeal more to the Academy membership than the foreign press, so I'm guessing its Oscar chances are still quite good.

The biggest shock of the night was Best Director going to Julian Schnabel over the Coen Brothers — again something that can be chalked up to the foreigners voting for one of their own. This bodes well for Schnabel's chance at a Best Director Oscar nod and could mean the film itself has a chance.

The acting awards were more predictable, with Daniel Day Lewis, Julie Christie, Marion Cotillard, Johnny Depp, Cate Blanchett and Javier Bardem taking home trophies. My guess is at least three of those winners take home the Oscar as well.